Switching your print on demand supplier? Get in touch with us here

1. Shopify vs. Amazon: An overview

Shopify vs. Amazon: Which platform is right for you?

Are you ready to enter the bustling world of ecommerce but feel overwhelmed about choosing the right platform? With Shopify and Amazon leading the charge, knowing which one aligns with your business ambitions can be challenging.

In this blog, we'll examine the features and benefits of Shopify vs. Amazon, helping you decide which platform is your business's perfect match. We'll explore everything from customizable storefronts and smooth integrations like Gelato with Shopify to Amazon's vast customer reach and hassle-free fulfillment processes.

Main takeaways from this article:

  • Shopify offers comprehensive customization and branding opportunities, which are ideal for sellers who want full control over their brand.

  • Amazon's online marketplace provides extensive customer reach with robust fulfillment options suitable for sellers prioritizing high sales volumes.

  • Shopify allows for scalable business growth with numerous app integrations but requires marketing and traffic management.

  • Amazon storefronts come with higher fees and limited personalization, adhering strictly to Amazon's rules and guidelines.

Shopify vs. Amazon: An overview

overview of ecommerce platforms

The fundamental distinction between Shopify and Amazon lies in their approach to ecommerce. Let's take a look at how each platform operates:

Business model

Shopify is a fully customizable platform where you can set up a store and sell online. In contrast, Amazon functions as a marketplace where numerous sellers list their products to reach Amazon's extensive audience.

Control and flexibility

Shopify allows greater control over branding, design, and customer interactions, aligning with your unique business vision. Amazon restricts these aspects to maintain a consistent marketplace experience.

Market reach

Amazon's massive customer base can potentially increase sales without much marketing effort and help you reach a broader global audience. At the same time, Shopify requires you to build and drive traffic to your store.

Fulfillment options

With Shopify, you manage fulfillment and can integrate solutions like Gelato forprint on demand, whereas Amazon offers Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) to streamline storage and shipping. Both have their pros and cons.

Key features of a Shopify store

Shopify store features overview

Let's explore some of the features that Shopify offers that make it a strong contender in the ecommerce world.

Customization and branding

Create a smooth brand experience with customizable themes and an array of apps. As you mold your store to match your vision, Shopify empowers you to develop a distinctive brand presence.

Emphasizing brand identity, Shopify allows you to take the reins of customer relationship management, ensuring your online presence mirrors your unique business ethos.

Payment processing

Shopify stands out here with its built-in system, Shopify Payments, powered by Stripe. This feature allows you to accept credit card payments directly, simplifying transactions.

You can also integrate third-party payment providers like PayPal for added flexibility. Shopify's payment processing is designed to be smooth and hassle-free.

Scalability and apps

Its expansive app ecosystem, featuring thousands of apps, empowers sellers to enhance their stores with specialized functionalities.

Whether you're a solo entrepreneur or handling multiple large-scale operations, Shopify adapts to your needs. Integrations available in the Shopify App Store, like marketing tools, analytics, and customer support features, allow for expansion.

Customer relationship

The Shopify platform enables you to gather valuable customer data and insights, personalize their shopping experience, and build strong, lasting relationships through effective communication.

Shopify gives you the ecommerce tools tocreate loyalty programs, recommend products, and engagedirectly through email marketing. All this means that you can tailor your marketing strategies to your audience's needs.

Key features of an Amazon online store

Amazon seller tools and dashboard

Now, let's take a look at Amazon's key features below.

Customer reach

Amazon is synonymous with scale. With its staggering global reach, products have the potential to be seen by millions—an alluring prospect for any seller.  Amazon's platform naturally leads high-intent shoppers to your products, especially with discount codes, increasing sales.

Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA)

Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) is a popular service that takes the hassle out of logistics by allowing sellers to store their products in Amazon's fulfillment centers.

Once a customer places an order, Amazon handles packing, shipping, and even customer service on behalf of the seller. This smooth process saves time and enhances customer trust and satisfaction.

Ease of use

It provides an easy setup and intuitive interface that lets sellers start their ecommerce journey without a hassle. Creating a storefront becomes a breeze with no technical expertise required, allowing sellers to focus on growing their business.

Amazon's extensive catalog system simplifies product listings, making it easier for potential customers to find what they need.

Limitations on branding

Sellers often find themselves confined to preset templates, which restricts their ability to establish a unique brand identity. Unlike Shopify, which offers extensive customization, Amazon's focus is more product-centric rather than brand-centric.

As a result, sellers have to work within Amazon's parameters, making it challenging to distinguish their brand from competitors.

Shopify disadvantages

While Shopify offers plenty of benefits, a few challenges must be considered. Let's explore these disadvantages below.

Marketing and traffic are your responsibility

When running a Shopify store, generating traffic and marketing your brand comes down to you. Unlike Amazon’s vast marketplace, where millions of potential buyers browse daily, Shopify requires a proactive approach. This means investing time and resources into search engine optimization, social media marketing, and possibly paid ads to attract visitors.

Subscription and transaction fees

The platform's subscription plans range from Basic to Advanced, with each offering different features at varying price points.

Shopify charges a transaction fee for each sale unless you use Shopify Payments, its integrated payment gateway. While the fees can seem high, they fund essential tools and services that help you successfully run and scale your ecommerce business.

Steeper learning curve

Beginners may find the initial setup time-consuming, requiring much effort to understand the platform's full potential. The learning curve can be steeper than expected due to the need for technical skills or hiring a professional to get started.

However, once you overcome this hurdle, the advanced features and customization pay off, giving you full control over the look and feel of your store.

No built-in marketplace

When setting up shop with Shopify, keep in mind there's no built-in marketplace at your disposal. Unlike platforms like Amazon, Shopify offers a blank canvas—perfect for those eager to carve out their niche, but challenging if you’re looking for a ready-made audience. You'll need to drive all your traffic, taking charge of marketing and customer acquisition from day one.

Amazon disadvantages

While Amazon presents an incredible opportunity to reach a large audience, it also has some downsides. Let's explore them below.

High fees

The fee structure can be complex, including referral fees, high-volume listing fees, and fulfillment fees that vary depending on the product category and whether you're using Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA). These can affect your profit margins, especially as your sales volume grows.

While your product may reach a large audience, weighing these costs against potential sales is important.

Limited branding and customization

If you opt for Amazon, expect some constraints on how you can portray your brand. Amazon operates under a universal structure, prioritizing consistency over individuality.

Customization options are notably limited; your products will share the same layout and design as countless others. This could be a critical drawback if standing out with a unique brand vibe is important. 

Fierce competition

You're not just up against other small businesses; established brands and sellers and Amazon themselves vie for customer attention. This can make it challenging to stand out, especially regarding pricing wars, supply chain efficiencies, and promotional strategies.

To succeed, you must differentiate your offerings and deliver exceptional value to attract potential buyers amid the crowded marketplace. 

Reliance on Amazon’s rules

This reliance means you have limited control over your business operations and could lose access to the platform if Amazon's strategic goals shift.

Some sellers are frustrated by these constraints, as they must consistently adapt to maintain compliance. Disputes with Amazon can sometimes be resolved slowly, impacting your sales and operations during the interim.

Comparing fees: Shopify vs. Amazon

comparison of Shopify and Amazon fees

When it comes to choosing between Shopify and Amazon, understanding the fee structures is crucial for maximizing profits. Let's examine the structures below.

Shopify fees

Shopify offers a tiered pricing structure with plans designed to accommodate different business needs. The Basic Shopify plan starts at $39 per month, with transaction fees of 2.9% if you opt not to use Shopify Payments.

The more advanced plans, Shopify at $105 and Advanced Shopify at $399 per month, come with reduced fees of 2.6% to 2.4%, respectively.

Amazon fees

If we look at Amazon's fee structure, sellers typically encounter a combination of referral fees, closing fees, and additional charges linked to category-specific listings. The referral fee, a percentage of each sale, varies from 6% to 45%, depending on the product category.

On top of that, there's a monthly subscription fee for professional sellers, priced at a flat rate, while individual sellers pay per item sold.

Ideal sellers for a Shopify store

With all this information at your disposal, let's identify the types of sellers for whom Shopify might be the perfect match.

Sellers who want full branding control

If establishing a robust brand presence is your priority, Shopify is a great choice. You're the captain of the ship, with complete command over your store's appearance and customer interactions. Whether customizing your website design or building a unique brand story, Shopify lets you shape every aspect.

Sellers focused on building a scalable ecommerce business

Shopify empowers sellers with access to apps and integrations that can streamline operations, enhance customer experience, and efficiently manage increased demand.

Its ability to handle high-volume traffic and transactions makes it an ideal choice for entrepreneurs targeting exponential growth. Plus, with Shopify’s customizable sales channels, you can easily expand your horizons.

Entrepreneurs looking for flexible integrations

For entrepreneurs wanting smooth integrations, Shopify’s extensive app ecosystem stands out. Shopify offers flexibility, whether you're syncing your inventory, simplifying order management, or connecting your store with social media platforms.

Its robust API ensures effortless incorporation of custom solutions or third-party services, making it ideal for tech-savvy sellers.

Ideal sellers for an Amazon storefront

Now that you know about Shopify sellers, let's discuss the ideal sellers for the Amazon storefront.

Sellers who prioritize high sales volume

With millions of potential buyers globally, Amazon offers an unparalleled opportunity to reach a broad audience. High-demand products can thrive, as the platform's extensive customer base naturally generates traffic.

Building a strong presence calls for strategic promotions and leveraging Amazon's tools to stand out, maximizing returns on investment through sheer sales volume.

Entrepreneurs with niche products and existing demand

For entrepreneurs whose niche products already have a loyal following, an Amazon storefront can provide a lucrative opportunity to tap into its massive user base.

With Amazon's search capabilities and millions of daily visitors, eager buyers have a higher chance of discovering your unique offerings. Leveraging Amazon's reputation can enhance consumer trust and accelerate sales.

Sellers who want a hands-off approach with fulfillment

If you want to simplify your ecommerce business, Amazon allows you to take advantage of FBA.

This service takes the burden off your shoulders by handling every aspect of order fulfillment, from storage to shipping. All you need to do is supply your products to Amazon's warehouses, and they will take care of the rest. This hands-off approach can benefit busy entrepreneurs.

Can Shopify and Amazon be used together?

Absolutely! Shopify and Amazon can be integrated, allowing you to harness the strengths of both platforms.

By syncing your Shopify store with Amazon, you can manage your ecommerce platform and business efficiently while expanding your product reach. This dynamic duo lets you enjoy Shopify’s customizable setup and branding alongside Amazon’s vast market and fulfillment options.

Grow your online store with Gelato

By now, it's clear that both platforms offer unique advantages tailored to diverse seller needs. Whether you're captivated by Shopify's branding freedom or drawn to Amazon's expansive reach, the choice hinges on your business goals. And Gelato can be your perfect partner for enhancing ecommerce success.

Gelato offers robust print on demand solutions, empowering you to create and sell custom products without the hassle of inventory. With features like global product distribution and effortless order management, Gelato streamlines your operations, letting you focus on growth. 

Gelato's integration with Shopify is a game-changer in so many ways. It lets you easily merge your store's creative potential with Gelato's print capabilities. Imagine designing unique, personalized merchandise and having it produced and delivered easily. 

Ready to take your online store to new heights?Sign up for Gelato today!

FAQs

Is Shopify better than Amazon?

Whether Shopify is better than Amazon depends on your business goals. Shopify offers extensive customization and control, which is ideal for brand-focused sellers. With its vast customer base and fulfillment options, Amazon suits those who prioritize sales volume and ease of use.

Do both Amazon and Shopify offer dropshipping?

Yes, both platforms support dropshipping. Shopify offers extensive flexibility with various dropshipping apps that smoothly integrate, allowing a broader range of products. Amazon allows dropshipping but follows stricter rules and guidelines for sellers. Both entail shipping fees.

What's the difference between Shopify and Amazon?

Shopify is an ecommerce platform that allows individuals to create their own branded online stores, offering full control over customization and commerce. Amazon, on the other hand, is a marketplace with a vast customer base.

Share:

Next steps

Start selling products with Gelato