Switching your print on demand supplier? Get in touch with us here

1. Understanding the fundamentals of customer loyalty

How to build a winning ecommerce loyalty program (+ examples)

Creating a successful loyalty program is not just about rewarding purchases; it's the art of fostering lasting relationships with your customers. Let's explore the strategies that turn occasional buyers into loyal brand advocates. We'll explore innovative reward structures, personalized customer experiences, and data-driven insights that elevate your program beyond the ordinary.

Join us in unlocking the secrets to building a loyalty program that truly connects with your customers and sets your brand apart.

Main takeaways from this article:

  • Ecommerce loyalty programs are about building lasting customer relationships through quality products, exceptional service, and consistent brand experiences.

  • Design loyalty programs tailored to customer profiles with a mix of rewards, leveraging technology for program management and enhanced customer engagement.

  • Successful examples include Sephora's Beauty Insider, Amazon Prime, Starbucks Rewards, and DSW VIP, demonstrating varied approaches to customer loyalty.

  • Promote loyalty programs using multiple channels like email, social media, influencer partnerships, and collaborations, focusing on creating a sense of exclusivity.

  • Measure program success through metrics like sign-ups, active memberships, redemption rates, and average order value, and integrate POD services for scalable, customized, and eco-friendly rewards.


Understanding the fundamentals of customer loyalty

Customer loyalty isn't just about making a sale; it's about creating a relationship with your customers that motivates them to continually choose your company over your competitors. A business with loyal customers has a more predictable revenue stream and a stronger brand, not to mention the power of word-of-mouth advertising from happy, committed customers. So, how do you build this coveted customer loyalty?

  • Quality products and services: The first step toward earning customer loyalty is providing high-quality products and services that fulfill your customers' needs. When a product or service surpasses expectations, customers are more likely to return.

  • Great customer service: Besides quality, customers appreciate when businesses go above and beyond to ensure their satisfaction. Whether you resolve issues swiftly, reply to queries promptly, or provide a pain-free return and exchange policy, exceptional customer service can differentiate you in a competitive market.

  • Consistency: Another key component of customer loyalty is consistency. Customers appreciate knowing what they can expect each time they interact with your company, be it service, product quality, or brand tone.

Utilizing feedback to cultivate loyalty 

Communication is key to any relationship, and the business-customer relationship is no different. Providing channels for customer feedback not only shows that you value their opinion but also gives you invaluable data to enhance your products, services, and overall customer experience. 

An effective ecommerce loyalty program, like any good relationship, is a two-way street. Not only does it reward customers for their continued patronage, but it also helps businesses by providing invaluable customer data, increased brand awareness, and higher customer retention rates.

Customer retention vs. customer acquisition

Consider this: acquiring a new customer can cost five times more than retaining an existing customer. Additionally, increasing customer retention by just 5% can increase profits by up to 95%, according to research by Bain & Company. But why is this the case? Let's delve deeper into the psychology of customer retention versus customer acquisition. 

The economics of customer retention 

Here's the surprising reality. Existing customers drive higher Customer Lifetime Value for your business. These customers are more likely to try new products, are less likely to switch to a competitor, and can become strong advocates for your company, effectively becoming another channel for acquiring new customers. Plus, transactions with repeat customers often involve less time, effort, and expense than transactions with new customers. 

The trust factor 

In terms of psychology, trust plays a massive role in building long-term customer relationships. When a customer feels comfortable with a brand - as they can trust the product's quality, the pricing, the service, and know what to expect - they'll come back for more. They're not just loyal because of rational reasons (like price or convenience) but for emotional reasons too. This is why customer experience is a crucial factor in retention. 

Understanding acquisition appeal 

Of course, acquiring new customers is not without its benefits. New customers are vital for business growth. They bring in new energy, fresh perspectives and can help tap into markets you hadn't previously considered. The excitement and novelty of being a 'new' customer can be a thrill in its own right, driving initial engagement. 

However, the goal should be to convert those new customers into loyal, repeat customers as quickly and efficiently as possible. That's where your ecommerce loyalty program comes into play. By offering incentives, rewards, and personalized experiences, you are priming these new customers to become your business' loyal supporters.


Designing your own loyalty program tailored to your target audience

Creating a loyalty program that fits your target audience like a glove is crucial. Remember, one-size-fits-all simply does not hold in the realm of customer loyalty programs. Your approach should be unique and tailored to your brand and customers. So, let’s discuss a step-by-step guide on how to custom-design your loyalty program. 

1. Profiling your customers

Group your customers based on buying behavior, preferences, and feedback. Then, define what motivates each group. You can use market research, surveys, or customer interviews for this task. Now, devise unique strategies to please each group. For example, a cosmetics brand can offer skincare tips, makeup tutorials, or exclusive access to new product launches to engage beauty enthusiasts, while occasional shoppers could be incentivized with targeted discounts. 

2. Crafting a rewards structure 

An effective reward structure can do wonders for your loyalty and rewards programs. The key is to offer rewards that resonate with your potential loyalty program members. Consider using a tier system that increases rewards as customers move up levels. This creates a sense of achievement and encourages further shopping. You could also include a mix of monetary and non-monetary rewards. Money off vouchers, free shipping, priority access, unique experiences - experiment to see what works best for your audience.

3. Leveraging technology 

It's time to harness tech tools to streamline the process. Customer Relationship Management (CRM) systems can gather and analyze customer data, define customer segments, and track loyalty program performance. In contrast, ecommerce platforms can help manage your online storefront, making it easy for customers to access and redeem their rewards.

Real-life examples of the best ecommerce loyalty programs

When considering constructing an ecommerce loyalty program, real-world examples can provide inspirational direction. Let's peek behind the curtain and see how a few successful ecommerce businesses have shaped their loyalty programs.

1. Sephora's Beauty Insider

Sephora's Beauty Insider program excels because it offers a tiered reward system that encourages repeat purchases. Customers can climb the ladder from 'Insider' to 'VIB' (Very Important Beauty Insider), and finally, 'Rouge' status as they spend more. Benefits include access to exclusive sale events, birthday gifts, and free shipping. Moreover, the points earned can be redeemed for exciting beauty products, making the reward tangible and desirable. 

2. Amazon Prime

Amazon elevates its loyalty program by focusing on the overall customer experience. A Prime membership, for instance, offers free two-day shipping, access to music and video streaming services, and exclusive deals during sales events. By integrating its loyalty program into various aspects of the customer journey, Amazon successfully creates an ecosystem that promotes repeat business. 

3. Starbucks' rewards program

Starbucks has designed a user-friendly mobile app experience for its reward program members. With every purchase, customers earn 'stars', which can be redeemed for free drinks and food. Plus, their mobile order & pay feature drives convenience for customers who are in a rush. They've made both earning and redeeming rewards an enjoyable and seamless process. 


Shoe retailer DSW has leveraged its VIP program to enhance customer satisfaction. The program has an easy-to-understand point system where members earn points for every dollar spent, with bonus points on their birthday. VIP status also includes free shipping, access to exclusive events, and even donation opportunities, encouraging a feel-good vibe for members.


Methods to promote your ecommerce loyalty program

After you've laid the foundation and built an excellent loyalty or referral program, it's time to share it with the world. Here are some effective methods to promote your customer loyalty program.

  • Email marketing: Use this established channel to introduce your new loyalty program to your existing subscriber base. Ensure to highlight the program's benefits, how to join, and how to earn and redeem rewards. Personalize emails as much as possible for a proven uptick in open rates.

  • Social media: Leverage your social platforms to generate buzz around your loyalty program. Offer exclusive sneak peeks into the rewards or share user-generated content from happy members. Don't forget to use appropriate hashtags to increase visibility.

  • Website & mobile app: Use homepage banners, pop-up messages, and a dedicated loyalty page to convey your loyalty program’s value. If you have an app, app notifications can be a very effective way to get your message across.

  • Influencer partnerships: Partner with influencers who align with your brand's values and target market to boost your loyalty program's exposure. Encourage them to create content showing their experiences with your program.

  • Collaborations & cross-promotions: Join forces with another brand that complements yours, but it’s not a direct competitor. This approach allows both brands to potentially tap into each other's customer base.

Quick Tip: While promoting a loyalty program, it's essential to create a sense of exclusiveness. Remember, people want to feel special. So, make them feel like they’re getting access to a club or a community.

Checking the pulse: Measuring the success of your rewards program 

After your loyalty program is up and running, and you’ve applied some of the promotional techniques above, it's critical to measure its success.

  • Track the number of sign-ups

  • Gauge ongoing engagement

  • Assess the effectiveness of rewards

  • Evaluate spending patterns

  • Identify areas needing improvement

The advantages of integrating a print on demand service

Think about it - what if your customers could access a loyal member-only store featuring limited-edition merchandising linked directly to your brand? Sounds exciting, doesn't it? This is where integrating a print on demand (POD) service into your loyalty program can add another value dimension for your customers. 

Let's explore the manifold benefits of marrying your ecommerce business with a POD service. 

Scalable and self-pacing 

With POD, the primary advantage is the 'print per demand' concept. That means there is no need to maintain a heavy stockpile or worry about not reaching a break-even point. The production scales with the demand, manufacturing only when an order is placed. This feature aligns seamlessly with the nature of loyalty programs, which are direct responses to the frequency and consistency of customer engagement. 

Cost-effective and efficient 

Incorporating a POD service can reduce the overhead of inventory and manufacturing management. As you only print what's needed, you eliminate the risk of dead stock or outdated merchandise. Plus, the production and fulfillment process is efficiently handled by the POD service provider, allowing you to focus on core business tasks. 

Customization galore 

A key selling point of POD services is the high level of customization it allows. Your loyal customers can indulge in personalized merchandise that resonates with their identity. This creates a unique opportunity to deepen your brand connection and maintain a memorable presence in your customers' lives. 

An eco-friendly approach 

Owing to the print on demand model, waste is significantly reduced, making it a more sustainable choice compared to traditional bulk manufacturing methods. By showcasing your brand's environmentally conscious efforts, you may attract a segment of eco-aware customers who appreciate such sustainable practices.


How Gelato's seamless production enhances loyalty programs

On-demand efficiency

Gelato's strength lies in its print on demand setup. This means that your significant investment in merchandise stock is a thing of the past. Your customers choose what they want, and only then is it produced and sent out. This efficiency saves on resources and makes your rewards scheme cost-effective and flexible. 

Global reach

It's a big world out there; with Gelato, you can reach it. We have hubs across the globe, meaning rapid, local delivery for your customers. This not only means instant gratification for your loyal customers but also a reduction in your business's carbon footprint. 

Top-quality merchandise

This isn't about offering cheap, forgettable items. It's about rewarding your customers with quality merchandise that they'll love and actually use. Gelato offers a wide range of products, from custom t-shirts and hoodies to personalized mugs, phone cases, and wall art. This allows for a truly customizable rewards scheme tailored to your audience.

Personalization at its best 

With Gelato, your rewards can genuinely speak to your customers. Have your logo printed on stylish apparel or your catchphrase emblazoned on a mug. Not only does this reward your customers, but it also gets your brand out there when your customers use or wear their goodies. That's clever marketing. 

Sign up for Gelato and start transforming your business today.


Next steps

Start selling products with Gelato