Switching your print on demand supplier? Get in touch with us here

1. Etsy and its potential for ecommerce sellers

How to open multiple Etsy shops and successfully drive sales

"Can you have more than one Etsy shop?," is a commonly asked question, and the answer is a resounding "Yes!" Many sellers find themselves contemplating expansion beyond a single shop while navigating the vibrant world of Etsy. While one storefront can certainly achieve success, diversifying into multiple stores can tap into varied niches, further boosting potential revenue. However, this venture is not just about launching additional shops; it's also about strategically positioning each one to maximize sales.

This guide will delve into the intricacies of managing multiple Etsy shops and unveil proven strategies to drive sales effectively. Whether you're a seasoned seller or setting up a new shop on Etsy, this guide will help you manage multiple Etsy shops.

Main takeaways from this article:

  • Etsy differentiates from other platforms by catering to a niche audience seeking handmade, vintage, and craft supplies.

  • Etsy offers sellers access to over 80 million active buyers and a suite of seller-friendly tools to run multiple shops.

  • Multiple Etsy shops help sellers specialize in varied niches, cater to diverse customer segments, and secure multiple revenue streams.

  • Cross-promotion between shops, SEO-optimized listings, strategic use of Etsy ads, and capturing and showcasing positive customer reviews are among the effective strategies to boost sales.

Etsy and its potential for ecommerce sellers

Etsy offers a unique niche. While other platforms, like eBay, might be a sea of generic products, Etsy stands out with its focus on handmade, vintage, and craft supplies. Imagine having a store in a community where everyone values creativity and craftsmanship. The audience on Etsy is a discerning one. They're not just looking for any old things; they want items with stories, history, and a personal touch. This means as a seller, you're catering to a clientele that truly values your work and is willing to pay for uniqueness.

While the ecommerce world can seem saturated, Etsy’s specific focus can be an advantage. Etsy boasts over 80 million active buyers, which means that with the right product and branding, you can really skyrocket your Etsy business. And the best part? Etsy comes equipped with a suite of seller-friendly tools, from insightful analytics to advertising options, designed to give your shop the spotlight it deserves.

Why you should open multiple shops on Etsy

Dipping your toes into the Etsy waters with one shop can be both thrilling and rewarding. But as your entrepreneurial spirit flourishes, you might wonder: "Why stop at one?" Let's unpack some compelling reasons to consider opening multiple shops on Etsy.

Specializing in different niches/products

Having separate shops allows you to dive deep into different niches. For example, one shop could be exclusively for handcrafted jewelry, while another might focus on custom-printed apparel. This ensures your products aren't lost in a sea of variety and provides clarity for customers searching for specialized items. Separate shops also help with tailored marketing campaigns. With separate shops, you can adopt specific strategies and make the distinction easier.

Meeting diverse customer needs

Different shops can cater to different customer segments. For instance, a shop selling baby apparel would have a different audience as compared to a shop selling home decor. By distinguishing your shops, you can provide a shopping experience tailored to each audience. Running multiple shops lets you have diverse feedback. These can be invaluable for product development, and ensuring customer insights are incorporated into the process can help you meet the varied needs of your target audience.

Diversifying revenue streams

Just as investors diversify their portfolios to mitigate risk, having multiple shops serves the same purpose. It acts as a safety net for your ecommerce business. If one shop faces a downturn, the others might still be thriving. Multiple shops also help you test out different markets and experiment with one shop while keeping the others stable.

Steps to open multiple Etsy shops

Are you eager to capitalize on the potential of having multiple Etsy shops? Fantastic! However, it's not just about creating a second Etsy account and uploading products. To truly benefit from this venture, meticulous planning and strategy are required for the two Etsy shops. Here are the essential steps to ensure your multiple Etsy stores not only exist but thrive. 

1. Ensure compliance with Etsy's policies


Before you open a second Etsy shop, acquaint yourself with Etsy's policies regarding multiple shops. It's crucial to ensure that each shop adheres to its guidelines. Being proactive in understanding and complying with the platform's policies safeguards your Etsy accounts.


Etsy requires sellers to declare all their shops. This maintains trust with the platform and your potential customers. Open disclosure not only reflects ethical business practices but also paves the way for clearer communication and more harmonious interactions with both Etsy and your clientele.

2. Decide on the niche for each shop


Look into market trends, customer demands, and any gaps you might be able to fill. A well-researched niche will have better chances of standing out. Being informed and proactive positions you ahead of the curve, allowing you to anticipate shifts and adapt effectively.

Passion meets profit

While profitability is essential, also consider what you're passionate about. An Etsy store built on passion often resonates more with its audience. When you infuse your work with genuine enthusiasm, it becomes infectious, drawing customers to the authentic energy of your brand.

3. Branding each shop distinctly

Logo, banner, and shop aesthetics

Each shop should have its unique logo and banner, reflecting its niche and ethos. Maintain a consistent color scheme, typography, and overall aesthetic, ensuring visitors instantly recognize and resonate with your brand.

Product photography

High-resolution, well-lit photos can make or break a sale. Invest time and, if necessary, equipment to get this right. Whether it's the angle, backdrop, or style, maintaining a consistent look across all product photos reinforces your brand identity.

4. Set up separate email accounts


Using different email accounts for each shop helps streamline communications, segregate order confirmations, and handle customer queries effectively. It not only declutters your inbox but also ensures timely responses, enhancing operational efficiency.


Having a dedicated email for each shop reinforces your brand's professionalism and makes managing customer interactions smoother. This level of dedication communicates your commitment to quality and attention to detail, elevating your brand's image in the eyes of the customer.

5. Configure payment and shipping for each shop

Customized preferences

Depending on your shop's niche, location, and target audience, your payment and shipping preferences may vary. Tailoring these details for each shop ensures smoother transactions and happier customers. Also, you can use the same credit card and bank account to register yourself for Etsy payments. 


Always be clear with your customers about shipping durations, payment methods accepted, and any potential delays. This builds trust and reduces the chance of misunderstandings. Moreover, fostering a transparent relationship demonstrates respect for your customers.

Tips for successfully managing multiple shops

Juggling multiple Etsy shops might sound like a Herculean task, but with the right approach, it's not only feasible but also remarkably rewarding. As the saying goes, "It's not about working harder; it's about working smarter." Here are some useful tips to ensure you manage your multiple shops efficiently.

Tip #1: Use tools and software to streamline processes

Inventory management

Tools like Stitch Labs or Inventory Source can be lifesavers. They help you keep tabs on your stock levels across shops, ensuring you always have enough and never overcommit or run out of the bestsellers.

Unified messaging

Consider applications like HelpScout or Zendesk. They can compile customer queries from all your shops into a single dashboard, making communication seamless and swift. Centralizing interactions ensures consistent and timely responses, enhancing customer satisfaction.

Tip #2: Use a calendar to schedule product launches and promotions

Planned launches

Instead of sporadically launching products, a content calendar can help you strategically introduce them, ensuring each shop gets its time in the spotlight. This systematic approach allows you to effectively allocate marketing efforts and resources, maximizing the impact of each launch.

Seasonal promotions

Planning ahead for holiday sales, seasonal discounts, or themed promotions can drive significant traffic and sales. A calendar ensures none of your shops miss out on these golden opportunities.

Tip #3: Allocate time blocks for each shop’s tasks

Structured workflow

Assign specific hours or days for each shop's upkeep. For instance, Mondays could be for Shop A, Tuesdays for Shop B, and so forth. This helps prevent tasks from overlapping and keeps you focused.

Avoiding burnout

While passion is the fuel for any venture, it's necessary to power down and take breaks. These intervals can refresh you and make sure that each shop gets your best energy and creativity without compromise.

Tip #4: Track performance metrics for each shop to identify growth areas

Data-driven decisions

Regularly and consistently review performance metrics like sales figures, customer reviews, and website traffic and analyze them to derive valuable insights. Tools like Google Analytics or Etsy's built-in analytics can help you do this.

Continuous improvement

By understanding what's working and what's not, you can tweak your strategies, ensuring each shop continually evolves and grows. Embracing a mindset of adaptability will boost sales and future-proof your business in a dynamic marketplace.

Strategies to drive sales across your shops

So, you've set up multiple Etsy shops, each uniquely tailored and packed with products. But how do you ensure that these items don’t just sit pretty, but actually move off the digital shelves? Here are some actionable strategies to amplify sales across your multiple Etsy shops.

1. Cross-promote between your shops

  • Offer bundle deals: How about a special offer where buying a handcrafted necklace from Shop A gives a discount on a vintage clutch in Shop B? Bundle deals can intrigue customers to explore and buy from your other shops.

  • Use promotional cards: Slip a beautifully designed promotional card into each package, highlighting your other shops and what they offer. A packaging insert is a simple but sure-shot way to introduce your buyers to the broader range of products available across your shops.

2. Optimize listings for SEO

  • Implement keyword research: Use Etsy's search trends or tools like Marmalead or eRank. Pinpoint what potential buyers are searching for and integrate those keywords naturally into your product titles, tags, and descriptions.

  • Write quality product descriptions: Beyond SEO, ensure your product descriptions are clear and compelling, and provide all necessary information. A well-informed buyer is more likely to press 'add to cart' when they know what they're buying.

3. Utilize tailored social media marketing

  • Platform choice: Depending on the shop's niche, different platforms might be more effective. For instance, a shop selling vintage posters might thrive on Pinterest, while handcrafted jewelry might get more traction on Instagram.

  • Engaging content: Don't just promote products. Share behind-the-scenes glimpses, customer testimonials, and stories behind each creation to add sentimental value to each creation. Craft content that resonates and connects with your target audience.

4. Invest in Etsy ads strategically

  • Targeted advertising: When you use Etsy's advertising platform, be specific about which products you promote. It might be your bestsellers, items with the best margins, or products that introduce buyers to a wider range.

  • Budget wisely: Adjust your budget based on what's yielding results to ensure you're getting the best bang for your buck. An adjustable budget strategy allows you to pivot quickly, optimizing your investments and capitalizing on emerging opportunities.

5. Collect and showcase positive reviews

  • Encourage feedback: After a successful sale, gently nudge your customer to leave a review. A heartfelt message expressing gratitude and highlighting the importance of their feedback can work wonders.

  • Spotlight reviews: Feature glowing reviews prominently in your shop and on social media. By showcasing real experiences, you not only validate the quality of your products but also create a community feel around your brand.

6. Implement loyalty programs for repeat customers

  • Loyalty points: Introduce a system where repeat purchases earn points that can be redeemed for discounts or freebies. A structured loyalty program can also turn occasional buyers into brand advocates, amplifying word-of-mouth marketing

  • Exclusive offers: Periodically offer special discounts or early access to new products for returning customers. Such gestures boost sales and enhance the overall brand experience, making your shop memorable in a crowded marketplace.

Streamline your multi-shop Etsy business with Gelato

While there's no limit to how many Etsy shops you can have, running multiple Etsy shops can sometimes feel draining, especially if you're constantly balancing product creation, inventory management, and shipping logistics.

Gelato is a cutting-edge print on demand platform that's tailor-made for Etsy sellers looking to scale operations. With Gelato, you can expand your product offerings without worrying about managing inventory. Introduce various new products to your shops, such as custom t-shirts, mugs, phone cases, tote bags, and wall art. Gelato produces items only when orders come in, ensuring you don’t have unsold stock eating into your profits. 

Gelato offers effortless integration with Etsy, creating a seamless link between your shops and their expansive product range. The moment a customer places an order, Gelato springs into action without you lifting a finger. With facilities spread across the globe, products are crafted close to each buyer, ensuring quicker delivery times and satisfied repeat customers.

Gelato offers the perfect blend of efficiency, quality, and global reach to run a multi-shop Etsy business. If you want to turbocharge your Etsy business and ensure smooth sailing for all your shops, Gelato is the fuel you need. Sign up for Gelato now!


Next steps

Start selling products with Gelato