Switching your print on demand supplier? Get in touch with us here

1. What is affiliate marketing?

Affiliate marketing vs. dropshipping: What's best for you?

If you're an artist or creator with an online store, you might be wondering how to make a successful business out of your creations. In the ecommerce world, two business models yield significant profits: affiliate marketing and dropshipping. But which one is right for you? 

In this article, we'll explain both models in detail and explore their pros and cons to help you make an informed decision.

Main takeaways from this article:

  • Affiliate marketing involves promoting others' products to earn a commission per sale through tracked links, which is advantageous for those with an online presence.

  • Affiliate marketing has advantages, including low initial costs, scalability, and flexibility in product promotion. It also allows creators to focus on content and marketing rather than inventory.

  • However, in the affiliate marketing model, the earnings are tied to set commission rates, success is dependent on external product and marketing quality, and it requires ongoing marketing efforts.

  • Dropshipping allows sellers to offer products without stocking them. They purchase from a third party only after a customer buys, allowing them to focus on sales without inventory risks.

  • The advantages of the dropshipping business model are low startup costs, control over branding and product selection, flexibility to test markets, and scalable operations.

  • The limitations of dropshipping are lower profit margins due to costs and competition, less control over shipping and quality, and higher marketplace competition.

  • Both models can be lucrative. The affiliate marketing business model depends on traffic and conversion, while dropshipping offers control over pricing but requires strong branding and customer loyalty.

  • When choosing between dropshipping, affiliate marketing, and a hybrid approach, consider your personal strengths, brand vision, budget, and risk tolerance.

What is affiliate marketing?

Affiliate marketer at work

Affiliate marketing is a method where an individual joins an affiliate program and gets paid to promote products from another individual or company. The affiliate marketer finds a product they like, advertises it and earns a portion of the profit for each sale made via the affiliate link. These sales are monitored through affiliate links between different websites. 

Taking the affiliate marketing route is an effective way to boost sales and create substantial online income, and it is highly advantageous for both brands and affiliate marketers.

Advantages of an affiliate marketing business

Affiliate marketing offers a compelling path to online success, particularly for artists and creators who already have a strong online presence. Let's delve deeper into the key advantages that make this model so attractive:

  • Low startup costs: You don't need to invest in inventory or manage fulfillment, making it a budget-friendly option.

  • Scalability: Your earning potential is virtually limitless. The more traffic you drive to a product, the more commissions you can generate.

  • Flexibility: You can promote multiple brands and products, catering to a wider audience.

  • Focus on creativity: You can channel your energy into building a strong online presence and content marketing strategy.

Affiliate business limitations

Like every model, affiliate marketing has limitations. Here, we'll explore some key considerations to keep in mind before diving headfirst into this model. 

  • Limited control over profit margins: Commissions are set by the brands you promote, giving you less control over your income potential.

  • Reliance on external factors: Your success hinges on the quality of the products you promote and the effectiveness of the brand's marketing efforts.

  • Requires ongoing marketing efforts: Building brand awareness and driving traffic takes time and consistent content creation.

What is dropshipping?

Dropshipping warehouse activity

Dropshipping is a fulfillment model employed by ecommerce entrepreneurs. In this model, a store owner sells items they don't have in stock. That is, when a customer places an order, the store buys the product from a third-party supplier, who then ships it directly to the customer. This means the seller doesn't handle the product directly, making it a low-risk, high-profit business model.

Advantages of a dropshipping business

Dropshipping presents a unique opportunity for creators and artists to expand their reach and potentially generate significant revenue. Let's explore the key advantages that make this model so appealing: 

  • Low startup costs: You don't need to invest in upfront inventory, minimizing financial risk.

  • Brand control: You curate your product selection and build your own brand identity.

  • Flexibility: You can test different products and niches without significant financial commitment.

  • Scalability: As your business grows, you can easily expand your product offerings.

Dropshipping limitations

Dropshipping also has its limitations. Let's look at some key challenges to consider before embarking on this business journey. 

  • Lower profit margins: To determine your profit, you'll need to factor in the cost of the product from the supplier, marketing expenses, and your markup.

  • Less control over fulfillment: You rely on the dropshipper's efficiency and quality control, which can impact customer experience.

  • Higher competition: Dropshipping is a popular model, so standing out in a crowded marketplace requires strong branding and marketing strategies.

Which one is the more profitable business model?

Calculating business profitability

The million-dollar question – which model unlocks greater profitability? The answer, like most things in business, isn't a simple one. 

Both affiliate marketing and dropshipping have the potential to be incredibly lucrative, but the key lies in understanding the factors that influence your earning potential. Let's dissect the hidden variables at play in each model:

Earning potential: Commissions vs. markups

  • Affiliate marketing: Your income hinges on the commission rates offered by brands, which can vary widely. You might earn a small percentage for promoting everyday items or a significant portion for high-ticket luxury goods. The challenge lies in driving enough traffic to generate substantial commissions.

  • Dropshipping: With dropshipping, you have more control over your earnings. You set the selling price for each product, factoring in the cost from the supplier, your marketing expenses, and your desired profit margin. This allows for potentially higher profit margins, but successful pricing strategies require careful consideration of market competition.

The power of influence: Traffic vs. brand control

  • Affiliate marketing: Building a loyal audience is paramount. Your success hinges on driving targeted traffic to the products you promote. The more people you convince of a product's value, the higher your commissions climb. This requires exceptional content marketing skills and a strong online presence.

  • Dropshipping: Brand control is king. You curate your product selection, build your brand identity, and cultivate customer loyalty. This allows you to develop a unique voice and establish a dedicated customer base that returns for repeat purchases. However, standing out in a crowded marketplace requires effective branding and marketing strategies.

Ultimately, the "more profitable" model depends on your strengths and resources. So, ask yourself these questions:

  • Do you have a strong online presence and content marketing expertise? If so, affiliate marketing might be a great fit.

  • Are you passionate about building a unique brand identity? If so, dropshipping could be your path to success.

  • Do you have a limited budget to start? No problem! Both dropshipping and affiliate marketing are low-investment and low-risk business models.

Choosing the right online business model for your own business

Entrepreneur weighing business options

So, you've weighed the pros and cons of affiliate marketing and dropshipping. Now comes the crucial step – making an informed decision that aligns with your entrepreneurial vision and resources.

1. Identify your strengths and passions

If you thrive on creating engaging content and building online communities, affiliate marketing might be a natural fit. Do you have a clear vision for your brand and a passion for building a unique identity? Dropshipping allows you to bring that vision to life.

2. Evaluate your resources

Both models require minimal upfront investment, making them ideal for budget-conscious entrepreneurs. However, dropshipping might require a slightly higher initial investment, depending on the products you choose to sell.

3. Analyze your risk tolerance

Affiliate marketing eliminates the risk of holding inventory, making it a safer option if you're new to ecommerce. On the other hand, dropshipping carries some inventory risk, but the potential for higher profit margins can be a worthwhile gamble for some.

4. Consider your time commitment

Affiliate marketing requires consistent content creation and audience engagement. Dropshipping demands effort on marketing and customer service to build brand loyalty.

Can you use a hybrid approach?

The beauty of an ecommerce business is its flexibility. You're not limited to choosing just one model. In fact, a hybrid approach can be a powerful strategy. Consider incorporating your dropshipping store with your affiliate website or starting a private-label dropshipping business to:

  • Expand your product offerings: Promote complementary products from other brands, enhancing your selection without the hassle of sourcing and managing additional inventory.

  • Increase profitability: Generate additional income streams through affiliate commissions while still enjoying the benefits of dropshipping.

Ultimately, the best online business model is the one that aligns with your strengths, resources, and long-term goals. By carefully considering these factors, you'll be well-equipped to choose the path that leads to ecommerce success.

Boost your profits with print on demand

Regardless of your chosen ecommerce path – affiliate marketing, dropshipping, or a hybrid approach – Gelato's print on demand (POD) platform can fuel your success.

Here's how Gelato empowers you:

  • Expand your product offerings: Offer high-quality custom-printed merchandise like t-shirts, hoodies, mugs, tote bags, phone cases, and more, all featuring your unique designs or artistic creations. This allows you to cater to a wider audience and leverage the ever-growing demand for personalized products.

  • Reduce inventory risk: Unlike traditional ecommerce models, POD eliminates the financial strain of upfront inventory purchases. Products are only printed when a customer places an order, minimizing the risk of deadstock and storage costs. This allows you to test new designs and product ideas without significant financial commitment.

  • Simplify fulfillment: Say goodbye to the complexities of packaging and shipping! Gelato handles everything from printing and quality control to secure packaging and global delivery. This frees up your valuable time and resources so you can focus on building your brand, marketing your products, and engaging with your customers.

  • Maximize profits: POD grants you control over your product pricing. Set your own margins to ensure you earn a healthy profit on every sale. This control over pricing allows you to experiment and find the sweet spot that maximizes your profitability.

Ready to turn your creative vision into profit? Sign up for Gelato today and explore the possibilities! Subscribe to one of our affordable plans that perfectly aligns with your business needs.


Which is better: dropshipping or affiliate marketing?

Choosing between dropshipping and affiliate marketing depends on your skills, resources, and what you want to achieve. If you're good at creating content and have a dedicated audience, think about affiliate marketing. 

However, if you're committed to running your own shop, dropshipping might suit you better. Both methods have their pros and cons, so it's key to consider your situation and business goals before deciding.

What is more profitable than dropshipping?

While dropshipping offers a good starting point, several business models can be even more profitable. Selling high-margin physical products with a significant markup between wholesale and retail prices can yield greater returns. Service-based businesses catering to specialized niches with limited competition can also be highly profitable. 

However, these options often require more upfront investment, strong marketing skills, and specialized knowledge.

Can you combine affiliate marketing and dropshipping?

Absolutely! This "hybrid" approach lets you leverage the strengths of both models. Promote affiliate products alongside your own dropshipped merchandise to expand your offerings and income streams.

Does affiliate marketing really pay?

Absolutely, affiliate marketing offers a lucrative way to earn money online, but it's not a get-rich-quick scheme. It requires strategic planning, consistent effort, and a focus on building meaningful relationships with your target audience. 

In most affiliate programs, commissions can be substantial, with some affiliates earning significant sums by promoting high-ticket items or products with recurring revenue models. However, building a loyal audience base and driving consistent traffic to these products takes time and dedication. 

Is affiliate marketing better than dropshipping?

The answer isn't a simple yes or no; whether affiliate marketing or dropshipping is better depends largely on your individual business needs and strategy. While affiliate marketing typically requires less upfront investment, dropshipping can potentially yield higher profit margins. The key is taking time to analyze the pros and cons of each business model.

Which is better: ecommerce or affiliate marketing?

The choice between ecommerce and affiliate marketing depends on your goals and resources. Ecommerce involves selling products directly and requires inventory management, whereas affiliate marketing involves promoting others' products for a commission, requiring less capital and inventory. Ecommerce offers higher potential revenue but also higher risks and responsibilities.

Is dropshipping actually worth doing?

Dropshipping can be good if done right. It lets you sell things without having to store them, which cuts costs. However, it sometimes means less profit, reliance on other companies for supplies, and possible issues with delivery. To do well in dropshipping, you need a great marketing strategy, reliable suppliers, and top-notch customer service.


Next steps

Start selling products with Gelato